Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Knight, PhD's avatar

I can remember the days in school when your teacher always had a dictionary in the classroom (usually right next to a thesaurus). There were times you would have to wait to use it because someone else in class was using it. My parents even had one at home! Could you find one today in a classroom...at least one that is used frequently?

And what about that thesaurus? Back before COVID, I had a research student who didn't even know what a thesaurus was. I have to believe he saw one somewhere, but he definitely never used it!

polistra's avatar

The very first 1840 version of Morse couldn't carry intonation, but later versions could. By 1870 harmonic telegraphs (humming instead of clicking) were common, used for multiplexing or for a simple kind of radio.

Morse plus intonation would have required a key with two movements, for instance turning a knob to vary the tone and pushing a button with one finger to make the pulses. It was physically and technically possible then, and would have been even easier in the radio era. This way of sending could be natural instead of dictionary-based, following the way real people coarticulate tones across syllables.

A few years ago I tried Morse with intonation for English prosody. I didn't like the results, so tried syllable length with more luck. The first version would have worked for Chinese or other tone-based languages.

https://polistrasmill.blogspot.com/2017/06/can-morse-carry-intonation-no.html

http://polistrasmill.blogspot.com/2017/06/can-morse-express-via-duration-yes.html

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?